***In the few months before and after the Draft last year, I made a series of topics stating my opinion about once a week on various things regarding our beloved football team. I felt it was some of my best posting by me since I've been on the site. I'm going to try and reintroduce that with this post.***
Yep, I'm breaking not only mine, but the site's rules, as I'm making another thread on Chad Pennington. We've heard it all, he's got a noodle arm, he's (and got) a *beep*, can't win the big games, no brawn all brains, is never going to be the same, basically everything negative in the book. However, no one, not any of us Chad supporters have really made a thread on him with logic and reasoning, just emotional anger and outrage. I'm going to try and put the Pennington situation in the words of his supporters.
There is no way Chad Pennington will start every game (or at least start every game when he can play) for the next 3 years. Impossible. We all know that. It would be an absolute stretch to say he'll start the next 2 years. Kellen Clemens is honestly the most important person on the QB depth chart, he's the future, we're building this team for Clemens, not Chad (like taking 2 linemen in the Draft last year, having a first year starting WR, etc).
Yet a lot of you like to talk of a team, without Chad, in the Super Bowl, within the next 3 years. Impossible. If you want to get in the Super Bowl, within 3 years, we would only do that with Chad. Maybe some Chad/Clemens combo, but Pennington MUST be included. The reason why is because of the same reason you knock on him, Pennington plays big when it counts.
Just look at this year. The most important games of every regular season are against divisional foes. In order to get to the big game, you have to beat the teams that are going to break the rail or push you back, just look at the Pats in their big years. I think in the AFC East, the style of play right now is strong defense, a good ball control, low turnover offense, and you win, which is the name of Pennington's game. He'd do terrible in the AFC South, with highpowered, score every second type of offenses win games.
Here is the turnover differential in divisional play for proof:
In 2 losses this year against the AFC East- (-1). The offense has commited 4 turnovers, all by Pennington (1 fumble, 3 INT).
In 4 wins this year against the AFC East- +6. The offense commited 1 turnover, an INT by Pennington (special teams commited other by Brad Kassel).
Here's New England:
In 2 losses this year against the AFC East- (-4)2
In 4 wins this year against the AFC East- +2. 4
Here's Miami-:
In 5 losses this year to the AFC East- (-5)
In 1 win (

) this year against the AFC East- +3
Here's Buffalo:
In 3 losses against the AFC East this year- (-4)
In 3 wins against the AFC East this year- +3
Notice, in our wins, we had the best turnover rate, at +6. You can credit Pennington for throwing only 1 INT there. Also, head to head matchup, Brady vs. Pennington:
Amount of turnovers in division wins:
Pennington-1
>Brady-4
Amount of turnovers in division losses:
Pennington-4<Brady-2Amount of turnovers overall against division:
Pennington-5
>Brady-6
So, Pennington beats Brady this year in a key component of winning in the AFC East, which resulted us in beating the Pats. Now, granted, we lost to the Pats in the playoffs, with Chad throwing a pick (garbage time) and officially credited with the fumble (partially his fault, mostly those who had the ball rolling on their feet though). But to say that Pennington's 300 yards and a 77 yard TD (longest in postseason history) were a failure is far from the truth.
Speaking of playoffs, Pennington has had success in the playoffs. In 5 starts, he's thrown for 1166 yards, so, in my head, that's roughly 226 yards a game. Not too bad to me. Really, the only bad game he had was in '02, completing less than 50% of his passes and throwing 2 INTs against the Raiders.
Bottom line: Pennington is a good QB who's really just a stop gap player. He's just here till Clemens is 100% ready for action. My hope is he can leave where Pennington left off, with a solid ball control offense not turning the ball over, which will win games in our division. I think he can do that, but I can only hope that he can get near where Chad was able to in not turning the ball over. I hope to see him start a game within 2 years, as he has a bright future ahead of him.
Just trying to scrape off some rust, and sorry for beating the dog, we'll get him some bandages (wow, Chad needing bandages, guess nothing's new).

Go at it......
Yes but one key thing there. Look at when we lose. Pennington's int's double Brady in that catagory, and it is in that which is one of our main beafs. When we win its because Pennigton hasnt blown the game. When we lose its because Pennington DID blow the game.
See the thing is also that Brady threw more ints in wins yes, but guess what? They still won! why? Because Tom Brady is the best qb in the NFL and can comeback after making mistakes to lead his team to a victory.
Chad cant do that. If Chad makes mistakes he can't bring the team back because he's what u said, a ball control guy, he cant do game winning drives and neva could, He doesnt have the arm for it.
See in the playoffs in 02 we blame brein for a lot, BUT what really happened? Yes Briend sux and id neva defend the guy but just wait a second here and listen first. Pennington 02 against Chargers did very well most of the game. But when we needed him to drive what happened? When Brady would get a 1st down on 3rd and long(it wasnt even 15 yards in this situation) What does Pennington do? WHat he always does dumps off a line of scrimage sideways pass to the fb for 1 yard and puts Brein to kick. Brien makes the game winning FG and all is forgotten about Pennington who choked and almost blew the game.
Then we go to the next game vs. the Steelers. Pennington has his worst game her ver played in the biggest game of his career. But he has a chance to take his team back to win. What happens? Sideline 1 yard gain again on 3rd down to give Brien, who sux, a chance to win the game with a 49 yard FG. Now 49 yards is long but an NFL kicker should be abel to make it, the only thing is NO ONE had ever made a FG over 47 yards at Heinz Field. So u have a kicker who doesnt have a strong leg kicking from a distance thats never been made on that field, REAL GOOD ODDS. what happens? he blows it.
But Pennington AGAIN has a chance to lead his team to victory. Again what happens? Pennignton gets conservative and sets up a 46 yard attempt which at that field is just inside the longest kick made. Still not great odds especially with a kicker who already blew one kick. What happens? Doink off the crossbar. This time he had the accuracy but not the distance. Yes Brady makes his team comeback a lot to win by setting up FG's but go check how many times outta all those game winners that Venateri had to kick from 46 yards or more....not many. If Pennignton would, or I should say COULD drive his team into easier FG range it would be a lot more great victories in Jets history.
So why u want Clemens, who is mobile and has a strong arm, to come into the Shotty offense, which is begging to be opened up, and only play conservative again is beyond me. Clemens is our future and our future is to finally Open up our offense again so we can score and win games when we need to, which almost every game in postseason is close and needs a comeback, and finally get rid of the 5-6 years of complaining about playcalling when we need to win games. Clemens is our meal ticket to a great offense. We can be explosive and comeback to win games. Pennignton cant do that, he can manage games and play NOT TO LOSE, and thats no way to play. When u play not to lose u rarely ever win the big games, i.e. Boise St. game this year agaisnt Oklahoma.
Everyone complains about the OC around here but fail to realize they cant call that many plays cus they are limited by Pennington. Wake up CALL! we kept changin offensive coordinators with different styles and yet we saw the same exact plays. Wonder why that is??? Pennington. 3 different guys with different styles come in and the same plays being called u gotta start to realize that somehting else needs to change and that change is Pennington.
Chadfropresidentino8 u said it PERFECTLY! Chad gives us the best chance to win DIVISIONAL GAMES. Unfortunately Our division's style isnt found throughout all the playoffs and the Super Bowl. So where as Chad is built to win in the Division, the reason he hasnt gotten us far in the playoffs is because that style doesnt work against teams outside our division. So u basically explained what ive been saying for months on here. Chad can win u regualr season games but when is he gunna win us more? Hes not. U even said it yourself without knowing.
So when Clemens finally comes in I will rejoice because even if He makes some abd decisions or throws ints in divisional games he has the ability pennington doesnt, Throw the ball down the field and play to win Games. The announcers pointed it out how many times this year, The Jets cant comeback to win games and they haven't. You wanna be like a 3 time Super Bowl Championship team u gotta be able to win in the Clutch, which means throwing passes down the field on deep outs to move the chanins and stop the clock, which we all have seen Pennington cant do and when he tries it looks worse than UGLY.
So I am waiting for the time where Clemens comes in cus then it will be great days, we might not win the SB that year or in 3 years, but we will get closer then Pennington could ever bring us or at least play with the OPPORTUNITY Penny could never give. Then Shotty will use the entire playbook and have all those great plays eveyrone wants, Then Baker will be involved more and show people how good he really is ALL OVER the field, then we will be able to RUN the ball better because people will have to respect the ENTIRE pass game, and then we will make BIG PLAYS and have exlectrifying scores and SB runs. People complain about a lotta problems but they fail to see through eitheir love of pennington too much or stubborness that ONE CHANGE can fix or at least greatly help SO MANY problems. When Clemens comes in he might not be great but he will be able to give us so much more to our team that we have been dieing and craving for for so many years, and thats a TRUE offense.