[SignalZero]

Who would win this game?

The 1986 Mets who finished the season at 108-54
or..
The 1998 Yankees who finished at 114-48

Here are the lineups....

Starter (ERA): David Cone 3.55 ERA
Lineup: 12BChuck Knoblauch2SSDerek Jeter3CFBernie Williams4LFPaul O'Neill51BTino Martinez6CJorge Posada7RFChad Curtis83BScott Brosius

Starter (ERA): Dwight Gooden 2.84
Lineup: 1CFLenny Dykstra22BWally Backman3RFDarryl Strawberry41BKeith Hernandez5CGary Carter6LFMookie Wilson7SSRafael Santana83BRay Knight

To see who won the game head on over to NEW YORK FANATIC for more information and the results.

[silversword55]

http://www.whatifspo...D=24246756&ad=1

THE YANKEES WIN! THHHHHHHHHHEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE YANKEES WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[SignalZero]

http://www.whatifspo...D=24246756&ad=1

THE YANKEES WIN! THHHHHHHHHHEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE YANKEES WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Don't go making changes to put a 5th starter up against your #1 so you can squeak out a win. Our #1 vs. your #1 was a win for the Mets.

[Maynard13]

that was a cool idea Ron, but I did one of my own, the 1908 Yankees vs the 1962 Mets.....the two teams franchise worsts.....and, since the Mets were a little more worse, I made the Yakees picther the #5, and the Yankees won 3-2
http://www.whatifspo...D=24251610&ad=1



lol, not really fair/fun whichever..but funny.

[Martin28]

Yo!

Not even close, '98 our boys won 125 games w/ a greta pitching rotation and a relentless offense. '98 Yanks win like 12-2, lol.

Adios!

[Chadforpresidentin08]

Yo!

      Not even close, '98 our boys won 125 games w/ a greta pitching rotation and a relentless offense. '98 Yanks win like 12-2, lol.

        Adios!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I'll say. The 98 Yankees were arguably the greatest team ever, the '86 Mets won with some luck.

[SignalZero]

I'll say. The 98 Yankees were arguably the greatest team ever, the '86 Mets won with some luck.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

You weren't even born yet. You have no idea how much magic and heart that team had.

[Chadforpresidentin08]

You weren't even born yet.  You have no idea how much magic and heart that team had.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I understand. But come on, if Bill Buckner wasn't there, who knows. Now sure, the Sox bullpen collapsed, but still, Buckner would make that play any other day.
And the '98 Yanks had heart, and magic, and they had me pulling for them

[matt x]

I understand. But come on, if Bill Buckner wasn't there, who knows. Now sure, the Sox bullpen collapsed, but still, Buckner would make that play any other day.
And the '98 Yanks had heart, and magic, and they had me pulling for them

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

you must remember, The mets had already tied the game before the Buckner play. When the mets did tie it ,The whole baseball world knew it was over . Even before the infamous buckner error.

[SignalZero]

I understand. But come on, if Bill Buckner wasn't there, who knows. Now sure, the Sox bullpen collapsed, but still, Buckner would make that play any other day.
And the '98 Yanks had heart, and magic, and they had me pulling for them

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

You can't say that. Who knows how his replacement would have done? You can't base the series on one play, one bounce of the ball. That's like saying what if Mookie hit a line drive over his head instead? The bottom line is the 86 Mets won and were one of the best teams ever in baseball.

The Mets in the 2000 Series had no real chance, especially after Piazza went into a fetal postion against Clemens ruining any chance for the rest of the series.

[Maynard13]

you must remember, The mets had already tied the game before the Buckner play.  When the mets did tie it ,The whole baseball world knew it was over . Even before the infamous buckner error.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Yea, thats why I hate everyone blaming Buckner, they all say, if Buckner made the play, the Sox woulda won, odds point that the Mets woulda, they had the momentum