FlyHiJets, on 15 October 2011 - 01:01 AM, said:
Okay......I was REALLY trying to keep this as somewhat civilized debate between us but you're either too lazy to read, too stubborn to actually see someone else's point of view or you're just plain stupid.
Let me repeat YET AGAIN......I HAVE NO ISSUE WITH ANYONE COMING HERE FOR AN EDUCATION. As long as they do it legally. How f***ing hard is it to adhere to a lousy 3.....let me repeat so you get it through those cinder blocks you have inside your head.....THREE requirements to get a student visa? I don't want to kill immigrants. Only criminals that are stealing from my wife and children. You can f*** with me personally as much as you want but when you start affecting my family, I really don't give a shit who you are.....criminal illegal alien, a cop, lawyer, judge or President f***ing Obama himself.......I will make you suffer. Death would be welcomed by the time I'd be done. And no.....I'm not trying to act tough or brag about my accomplishments. I know my accomplishments & I'll tell you something else.....I did everything on my own and WORKED for it and EARNED everything I have. I never had to steal from others to get what I wanted in life.
Well first I guess I'll start by debunking this it's easy to get a student visa nonsense.
Quote
Bhaskar Chitraju came to the United States from India at the age of 13, and has never been back, living legally in the U.S. for the past 10 years. In Southgate, Mich., he played soccer, excelled at Quiz Bowl, and indulged in Battlestar Galactica marathons with his buddies. High school was easy for him, he remembers, because people accepted him for who he was.
However, the aspiring business owner is as far from American citizenship as the day he stepped off the plane. And two years ago, a clock started ticking down on the only life he knows.
His father, a computer programmer, applied for a green card as soon as he could file the paperwork. Bhaskar would have benefited from that petition, but at 21, he was hit by a provision called “aging out” — a consequence of a visa processing backlog that affects thousands of aspiring Americans a year. He continues to live in the United States on a student visa, but Bhaskar may be legally obligated to leave after he graduates from business school next year.
“I feel frustrated and helpless most of the time,” said Bhaskar, who insists he is determined to play by the rules,. “There’s so much uncertainty in my life — I don’t know if I’ll be here next year or not.”
Reform for the Younger Generation
As green card backlogs delay or derail their chances for citizenship, people like Bhaskar are pinning their hopes on a controversial piece of legislation that was meant to address the quandaries of illegal — not legal — immigrants. The DREAM Act, or Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors, is a federal bill that would provide immigrant youth who enroll in college or serve in the military an expedited path to citizenship. It would also make it easier for states to offer undocumented immigrants in-state tuition at public colleges and universities.
The prospect of legalization for undocumented aliens, even a small portion of them, stirs passions on all sides of the immigration debate. Opponents say the DREAM Act amounts to amnesty for lawbreakers, while proponents stress it would benefit only those who entered the U.S. before age 16, have lived here for at least five years and have a clean criminal record. Versions of the bill foundered in the Senate four times since 2001, but bipartisan support may favor supporters this time around. In March, senators Dick Durbin, D-Ill., and Richard Lugar, R-Ind., reintroduced the bill in the Senate, while Howard Berman, D-Calif., and Lincoln Diaz-Balart, R-Fla., introduced a similar version in the House.
If it were to pass, the DREAM Act would immediately make 360,000 undocumented high school graduates ages 18 to 24 eligible for legal residency, according to the Migration Policy Institute.
Bhaskar hopes the DREAM Act will help him, too, even though he has never been undocumented. “I would be so happy,” he says. “I could work to pay my tuition. Most of my problems would be solved.”
After 9/11, immigrants faced increased security restrictions, severe backlogs in processing visas and an increasingly histrionic debate over immigration. Young immigrants — the documented battling new barriers to permanent residency, the undocumented in fear of deportation — quickly flocked to the DREAM Act. Its supporters, many of them undocumented, lobbied politicians, organized marches and spoke to the media, often at the risk of exposing their status.
In online discussion forums, so-called “legal DREAMies” draw parallels between documented and undocumented kids who were brought to the United States at a young age. Jason, a naturalized American from Barbados, is a frequent poster on dreamact.info, an activist site. Having experienced the immigration system both as an undocumented teen and a green card petitioner, he believes both groups deserve an expedited path to citizenship. “You can’t go ahead in life always looking over your shoulder,” he said. “The DREAM Act should be a comprehensive immigration reform for the younger generation.”
Legal immigrants say they need the DREAM Act because the current system punishes people who try to play by the rules. Every year, tens of thousands of skilled foreign workers, from geneticists to nurses to engineers, enter the United States on work visas. Many return to their home countries, but others decide to settle here. Last year 166,511 foreign workers and their family members received green cards, but many more remained in limbo between temporary status and permanent residency.
One such green card hopeful is Ganesh, an Indian computer consultant who came to the United States with his wife and son seven years ago. His visa, the H1-B, allows him to apply for a family green card through his employer, a process he expected would take two to three years. His son is now 19 and a student at the University of Michigan. “No one can differentiate him from an American,” said Ganesh, but he worries that his son’s chances of citizenship will be derailed on his 21st birthday.
Backlog Blues
Nearly a million people may be stuck in the current green card backlog, according to independent estimates — both the State Department and the Department of Homeland Security plead ignorance on the exact number. Even at its most efficient, the green card process can take more than a year, as each petition requires the approval of the Department of Labor, the State Department and the Department of Homeland Security. However, an annual per-country cap means that people from high-demand countries like Mexico, India, China and the Philippines have to wait years for a space to open up in the line for permanent residency. Fluctuations in processing times can cause further unpredictable delays. Many families wait more than a decade before receiving a final yea or nay on their green card petition.
Young people hoping to secure permanent residency through their immigrant parents have the most to lose from the delay. Families may petition for their green cards together, but dependents who turn 21 before reaching the final step must restart the process on their own. No matter how many years they have lived here, their options for staying in the U.S. are the same as any foreigner’s: They can marry a citizen, seek a student visa or try to secure a temporary worker visa like the H1-B, which also is subject to quotas. In essence, they go to the end of the green card line, possibly to wind up in some future backlog.
With no end in sight to the traffic jam, Ganesh sought reassurance in the DREAM Act. He reasoned that his son, a graduate of an American high school who has not left the country since arriving seven years ago, fit all the requirements. He later realized that the bill refers specifically to people who are under threat of deportation — i.e. the undocumented. He has not had the heart to tell his son, who is in the middle of exams. “I do not think politicians are aware of people like us,” Ganesh says. “If the senators realized how many people are in the same boat, I’m sure they would change the wording of the bill to preserve its spirit.”
That’s not a universal understanding of the bill’s spirit.
Some scoff at the idea that legal immigrants might lay claim to hardships of the core DREAM Act population. Undocumented youth live in constant danger of deportation, and they face a mandatory 10-year sanction if they go back to their home countries to apply for an American visa. Michael Olivas, director of the Institute of Higher Education Law and Governance at the University of Houston, bristles at the suggestion that legal students should benefit from a legislative victory by their undocumented peers. “If one of the (legal) kids ages out, they can go back to India and reapply,” he says. “The fact that these people feel sorry for themselves, well, that’s just not the Trail of Tears. They have many advantages. If they try to clamber aboard, that’s going to doom the DREAM Act.”
Advocates like Olivas are loath to make any changes to the DREAM Act that could endanger its long-fought support. In the absence of broader reform, narrow interest groups end up fighting for scraps of political will, says Aman Kapoor, founder and president of Immigration Voice, an advocacy group for legal immigrants. “Illegal immigration is a very important issue, because people are being exploited. But it has completely overshadowed legal immigrants,” he says.
In 2007, for instance, the House introduced a little-noticed provision to reduce the green card backlog by allowing unused visas to roll over from one year to another. That change would have made a major difference for people like Ganesh, but it was lost in the larger debate over border control and Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids.
Meanwhile, DREAM Act champion Sen. Durbin also advocates restrictions on the H1-B visa, the prime entry route for skilled immigrant workers. Kapoor sees a pattern. “Sometimes our members feel it would be better to flush their passport down the toilet. At least that way you’ll have your champions in Congress,” he said.
Some DREAM Act aspirants may take that idea literally. Lynne McCranor, an England-born ophthalmic researcher at the University of Indiana, says that bureaucratic delays caused her son to miss the family’s green card approval by just a few months. After struggling to do things by the book, she’d encourage him to drop his student visa and become illegal if it would help him gain permanent residency. “It makes a mockery of the DREAM Act, and I think the politicians need to realize that,” she said. “You’re forcing people to make very ugly choices.”
There are no guarantees that visa holders who deliberately become illegal would qualify for the DREAM Act — in fact, they could face steep penalties. Mark Hayes, a spokesman for DREAM Act co-sponsor Lugar, says that problems like the visa backlog will be weighed in the next round of comprehensive immigration reform — a weighty political undertaking that the Obama administration looks increasingly likely to postpone.
Here, Not Anywhere
Bhaskar Chitraju said he will support the DREAM Act whether or not it resolves his own visa problems. At the same time, he wonders why the very real prospect of losing his American life seems to count less because he is documented. He recently toyed with the idea of moving to Canada, which has a more open immigration policy for educated foreigners. India is also technically an option, though he doesn’t know anyone there.
He has rejected both options. “I want to start my business and live my life here. The people I care about are here,” he said. “I don’t want to be somewhere else for the sake of a permanent residency card.”
=====================================================
U.S. Visa Problems Still Hamper Foreign Students, Survey Suggests
Washington — The number of foreign students enrolled at American colleges and universities appears to be on the rebound, but the results of a study presented today at an international-education conference here suggest that the more-restrictive visa policies put in place after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks still may have a dampening effect on students and scholars coming to the United States.
Researchers at the University of California at Los Angeles presented the results of a 2007 electronic survey of 1,570 international students and academics, about 44 percent of the foreign students and scholars on the campus. The findings were presented at a session of the annual meeting of Nafsa: Association of International Educators, which wraps up today.
International students and scholars at UCLA reported that they had experienced delays at both American consulates abroad and ports of entry into the country. Thirty-eight percent of respondents with F-1 student visas and 56 percent of those with H1-B work visas said visa delays had forced them to alter their travel plans. Visitors from Africa were most likely to have had to delay their travel because of visa problems.
More than a third of all respondents said they had experienced delays at American consulates, while 39 percent of student-visa holders said they had been held up when attempting to enter the United States.
Many of those surveyed said that they worried visa issues were hindering their academic careers, said Shideh Hanassab, director of research at the university’s Dashew Center for International Scholars and Students and the author of a report on the study. In open-ended comments, respondents said that concerns about whether they would obtain a visa to re-enter the United States had prevented them from attending or delivering papers at international conferences.
A great many of those surveyed also expressed frustration with U.S. consular and customs officials whose attitudes, respondents said, made them feel like “criminals.” And 54 percent said the current immigration regulations did not make them feel safer.
Victor C. Johnson, senior adviser for public policy at Nafsa, said the UCLA findings illustrated the need for less-restrictive visa policies and for a coordinated federal approach to recruiting foreign students. —Karin Fischer
So people from other countries already have long waits just to get a visa. Now you want kids who have already lived here for most of their lives and went to school here K-12, to go to a country that they might not even remember living in, where they might not have any family left, and might not even speak that nations language. Meaning that they'd have to leave their family, friends, jobs, possibly children (who would be U.S. citizens) behind for an unknown length of time and risk never being able to return to the U.S., thus leaving everything they've ever known behind to chase a big MAYBE of actually ever becoming a U.S. citizen. And that's just to get a visa so applying for citizenship is a whole other process. And like SecondHand already mentioned there is A LOT of corruption in some of these third world countries where nothing is going to get done unless multiple officials are bribed. It would be like me going to Mexico to try to get a student visa. I don't know anybody in Mexico, it would be total culture shock, and I don't know anywhere near enough Spanish to get around. And that would be the case for a lot of people who's parents brought them here illegally as children or people who were children when their parents decided to stay here after their visas expired.
Quote
BUT....maybe I'm just different from you. I'll excuse you for it though since you're still young and haven't had to struggle to support your family YET. When you grow up and see that you don't get to just steal to get what you want in life, you may understand a little better. My wife has been wanting to return to school to finish her degree. Guess what? Because we're actual American citizens & make a combined salary of 70,000 per year, she doesn't qualify for any form of aid. Instead on our salaries, we get to support ourselves, and pay for my two children in high school as well as her son who just started his freshman year in college. WITHOUT a cent in financial aid. So take your whole statement of a feeling of entitlement and shove it up your pompous ass.
You don't know what I've been through in my life. You don't know what kind of sacrifices I've had to make for my family. In fact you don't know anything about me. So I don't know what makes you think I haven't struggled or made sacrifices. Now unlike you I don't feel the need to tell you about the sacrifices I've made to achieve the things I have achieved and the hard work I've done to get where I am today. I don't feel the need to give you my autobiography to validate my argument to you or to myself for that matter. But I'll put it this way and leave it at that, you're not the only person on this board who's worked hard and made sacrifices to get where he is today. And that's all I got to say on that topic.
Quote
As I stated previously, if you don't believe my credentials regarding teaching at the college, all you have to do is contact human resources and find out. Or are you too lazy to even do that since you apparently feel that people shouldn't actually have to DO things in life? I know this next statement doesn't mean a damn thing to you, but I like to actually speak my mind. I used to respect you and still do in many ways, BUT I have lost a great deal of respect for you considering you have shown your level of immaturity through your inability to debate a subject without personal attacks.
You lost a great deal of respect for me? Well now I'm all heart broken over that. I mean you may not know this, but I live just to get your respect. I don't know how I'm going to be able to sleep tonight knowing you've lost respect for me. My whole world is shattered now. But that's okay because I still love you.
Quote
As for anyone else on the forum, if I offended you with my views, I apologize for offending you, but I will not retract my statements.
As for my "knowledge" of how difficult it is to come here legally, it is likely more extensive than Mr. Bob Ross a.k.a. Mr. Jet.
Is the Bob Ross thing supposed to hurt my feelings or something. I like Bob Ross. He appeared to be a very peaceful and gentle man after spending time in the military. I still wish I could paint as well as he could.
Quote
We need to get our troops the hell back from the middle east and many other places around the globe.
And I can't agree more with that statement. See like I said I still love ya, (MSU beat the Muskrats again today so I'm REALLY in a good mood).