A1elbow, on 04 September 2012 - 02:15 PM, said:
But the two have higher ceilings and are much more of a "known" quality. Manning I imagine will be relatively successful, but I'm not sold on Decker until I see it. I just think it is a bad trade since if Newton doesn't have a sophomore slump it will be difficult for Manning to outscore him. He isn't in Indy anymore, I don't see John Fox looking to score 40+ a game.
if manning can still throw and is still in charge of the offense like he was at indy. i dont see why he wouldnt put up top 5 numbers decker will be the recipient of many of mannings tds. decker was on the cusp of being a fantasy starter last year with tebow throwing to him.
there was a lot of risk involved in this trade so i thought about this a bit. it could ultimately back fire for both of us.
jennings might finally have an off year or newton as you said could regress as a sophomore.