[MikeGangGreenFan2]

Im not big on McElroy I think hes a game manager. BUT!!!!!!!!! he did win today so I say give him a shot to start!!

[santana]

I think you slowly have to wean the fan base away from sanchez and tebow.. mcelroy is the logical choice.

[Jetsfan0099]

Start McElroy, Sanchez blows and you just can't sit there and keep starting him.

[a1elbow2.0]

I voted for McElroy. Starting Mark does nothing for Ryan or the team unless he came in and played better than he has ever played. If McElroy came in and the team played better than Ryan proves Sanchez held him back. If the team still sucks than it is as bad as the worst naysayers think.

[reg83ny]

Sanchez. And if he flops next week put McElroy in again. But don't get too hype folks. This was the Cardinals. Rex getting excited and all. But this team had me falling asleep watching the first half. Happy to see McElroy get to shine. He deserves it but this team will not win out

[FlyHiJets]

We can only pray that it is McElroy. He's earned the right to start by his performance today. The team definitely responded to him. On both sides of the ball. He's got smarts and the arm strength needed. He just needs to stop staring down receivers.

[jet-man]

reg83ny, on 02 December 2012 - 05:40 PM, said:

Sanchez. And if he flops next week put McElroy in again. But don't get too hype folks. This was the Cardinals. Rex getting excited and all. But this team had me falling asleep watching the first half. Happy to see McElroy get to shine. He deserves it but this team will not win out

i was just thinking the same thing. sanchez has the experience, but if he plays like doo-doo than yank him. mcelroy is sanchez from 2009 right now.

[Chaos]

reg83ny, on 02 December 2012 - 05:40 PM, said:

Sanchez. And if he flops next week put McElroy in again. But don't get too hype folks. This was the Cardinals. Rex getting excited and all. But this team had me falling asleep watching the first half. Happy to see McElroy get to shine. He deserves it but this team will not win out

2 issues with Sanchez starting:

1) Rex may never put McElroy in again. I'm still surprised he pulled Sanchez.

2) Tebow has to be activated soon. Who would you rather have Tebow or McElroy?

I rather McElroy get all the opportunities he can. Sanchez is done, complete shit this season.

[azjetfan]

I think it will be McElroy. He did not get to throw much but his passes where all catchable and on target except one that I saw. Lets see what he can do with a week of prep. I do think the Cardinals Offense is probably the only one worse than ours though.

[azjetfan]

Chaos, on 02 December 2012 - 06:35 PM, said:

2 issues with Sanchez starting:

1) Rex may never put McElroy in again. I'm still surprised he pulled Sanchez.

2) Tebow has to be activated soon. Who would you rather have Tebow or McElroy?

I rather McElroy get all the opportunities he can. Sanchez is done, complete shit this season.

1) I agree. I was hoping it would happen though. I am still shocked he pulled him.

2)I think McElroy has more upside. We are not going anywhere this season so lets see what we have in our young players so we can address the real areas of need in the Offseason

[Mr_Jet]

I don't know yet but I think the bigger question is does Clemens11 change his name to McElroy14 now or does he stick with Tebow15?

[V DidDy 210]

Clemons11 is an nyjetsfan institution.

[Smedsthejet]

It really depends on what the team's goals are going forward. If the front office and coaches are convinced that they'll move on from Sanchez in the offseason, then I'd expect McElroy to start (Tebow, even if he recovers in time, now appears out of the frame). But if they want to give themselves a better chance of winning and still see Mark being with the team next year (something they may be forced to given his contract situation), then I think Rex will go with Sanchez, with the warning that any repeat of his performance against Arizona will result in him being yanked far earlier than he was yesterday.

[JSOTF]

I will say this.

The play calling sucks. I mean seriously, we haven't fooled a single team with opening up the game with the play action pass! WTF is up with the run game being successful, and we have Sanchez still throwing the damn football to the other team? We started the game with a decent running attack (after said failed PA Pass to start the game.)

If it is TEBOW, we need to have him under center and run that way.
If it is Sanchez, we need to stick to the run.
If it is McElroy, we need to stick to the run.

Sean Greene had a good hard physical game, And I liked what I saw from Bilal Powell.
Run the f***ing football!

[a1elbow2.0]

This is the only team in the league where the starting QB get pulled and the guy who replaced him comes in an scores a TD to win the game...and people call for someone else to start next week.

It must be great for Tebow that no matter what he does, he is considered a success.

[FlyHiJets]

People need to stop thinking the team is going to move on from Sanchez next season. He's guaranteed 10 million in salary, so he's here no matter what unless someone comes along and is willing to take that off our hands. We need to dump Teblow & try to get McElroy groomed or developed because right now he's our best shot at winning since the team managed to detroy anything that Sanchez could have been. He had potential but that's likely gone now due to a lack of consistency at receiver, & a lack of trust in him as shown by putting in a bum every 3rd down until he got hurt. Now the kid has no faith or confidence in himself so he's doomed to either be a career backup or a washout.

I say let McElroy have the reins for the remainder of the season. We've got 4 games left against teams with sub 500 records. It can't hurt in any way. That's for damn sure.

[MikeGangGreenFan2]

What do we have to lose????? Let Greg play

[azjetfan]

FlyHiJets, on 03 December 2012 - 02:09 PM, said:

People need to stop thinking the team is going to move on from Sanchez next season. He's guaranteed 10 million in salary, so he's here no matter what unless someone comes along and is willing to take that off our hands.

I say let McElroy have the reins for the remainder of the season. We've got 4 games left against teams with sub 500 records. It can't hurt in any way. That's for damn sure.

Random thoughts
1) I wonder it Tanny has some verbiage in the contract where we could get out with less of a hit? I am sure he did not think Sanchez was great.
2) If our total $ for a position remains the same who cares? Cutting/ Trading Tebow will clear $ as well.
3) I would rather eat the cap and have a better player (if he is)
4) We also could do a trade were we keep some of the cap dollars.
5) There is always a way. Vern took a paycut for no reason that we know about.
6) I am all about letting McElroy play the rest of the year or until he proves he can't. We know what we have with Tim And Mark already.